What a mediator does — and does not do
The New York Courts’ divorce mediation guide describes the neutral’s role and screens out inappropriate cases. The court system also explains that lawyers may attend mediation or advise between sessions. Marital agreement formalities are set by DRL §236(B)(3).
A mediator is neutral. They do not act for either spouse, do not advocate for either position, and cannot advise either party on whether a proposed deal is a good one.
That neutrality is the value: a mediator can facilitate a conversation that two lawyers negotiating positionally might not. It is also the limit. The mediator facilitates an informed discussion and procedural fairness, but does not act as either spouse’s lawyer. Your own counsel can assess a proposal against your rights and circumstances.
This is why the standard advice is that each spouse has their own attorney review the agreement before signing. Not to relitigate mediation, but so that each person signs knowing what they are giving up.
What mediation covers
Everything a divorce has to resolve: property and debt, spousal maintenance, custody and parenting time, and child support.
The terms reached may be recorded in a memorandum and then drafted into an enforceable settlement agreement. A mediator may help identify issues, but each spouse should obtain independent legal advice. An uncontested divorce still requires the court process and a judgment.
When mediation works
- Both spouses can be in a room and negotiate
- Financial disclosure will be honest without formal discovery to compel it
- Neither has a significant informational advantage over the other
- The assets are reasonably straightforward
When it does not
- Domestic violence, or a significant power imbalance. Mediation assumes two people can advocate for themselves. Where that assumption fails, the process produces an agreement that reflects the imbalance.
- Suspected hidden assets. A mediator has no power to compel disclosure. If you think something is being concealed, you need discovery, which means a contested case.
- A complex or illiquid estate may require valuations and specialist advice before settlement. See High-Asset / Complex Divorce.
- Where one spouse simply will not engage.
Mediation, collaborative divorce, or lawyers negotiating?
| Feature | Mediation | Collaborative divorce | Attorney negotiation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neutral facilitator | Yes | May use a facilitator | Not required |
| Separate counsel | May advise or attend | Both spouses have counsel | Each lawyer represents their client |
| Commitment to avoid litigation | No collaborative participation commitment | Written participation agreement | Litigation remains available |
| Cost | Depends on agreement and work required | Depends on team and issues | Depends on negotiation and any litigation |
Mediation can reduce costs when the parties reach agreement, but the total depends on the work, fees, and whether litigation later becomes necessary. Counsel may advise between sessions or attend mediation. Collaborative divorce includes separate counsel and a written commitment to the collaborative process; ordinary attorney negotiation keeps litigation available.
Frequently asked questions
Does a mediator represent me?
No. A mediator is neutral and represents neither spouse. They cannot give either party legal advice.
Do I still need a lawyer if we mediate?
You should have your own attorney review the agreement before signing. The mediator cannot tell you whether the terms are fair to you.
Is a mediated agreement binding?
Enforceability depends on the document and its execution, not simply its label. A marital agreement under DRL §236(B)(3) must be written, signed, and properly acknowledged. It can be enforceable before a divorce judgment; only the judgment ends the marriage. Have counsel review the terms and formalities before signing.
How much does mediation cost?
Mediation can cost less when it resolves the issues efficiently. The total depends on the mediator’s fees, attorney review, drafting, valuations, and any later court work; it is not guaranteed to be the least expensive route.
What if mediation fails?
The divorce proceeds by negotiation between attorneys or through the court. Unlike collaborative divorce, a failed mediation does not require you to change lawyers.
Related: Collaborative Divorce · Uncontested Divorce · back to Divorce
Written by Dale Riedel, Esq. · Admitted in New York, Bar No. 5837539 · Last reviewed October 6, 2026
